should never be
U.S. policy

by Louis Vitale

Revelation of torture in Abu Ghraib and other U.S.-sponsored prisons have shocked the world. They also have brought the subject of torture and our country's participation in this practice into our consciousness. Perhaps even more shocking is the knowledge that torture has been practiced for years, right here in the Americas.

For the second time in the past four years, I find myself in a federal prison as a result of my protest against these inhumane policies. My country's involvement in torture was at the heart of my decision to leave my post as pastor of St. Boniface Catholic Church in San Francisco's Tenderloin District in order to speak out against these crimes.

I was arrested at the annual vigil and protest at Fort Benning, GA, home of the School of the Americas, which has been renamed the Western Hemisphere Institute for Security Cooperation. The Institute has trained Latin American military and police forces in counterinsurgency warfare for more than 60 years. Numerous graduates have been involved in documented human-rights abuses, including rape, torture and the massacre of innocent civilians in Latin America.

During the 1980s, I, and others from across the country, met with Archbishop Oscar Romero of San Salvador. He told us that the lot of many of his countrymen in El Salvador -- especially those working on behalf of the poor for economic justice and democratic political change -- was "to be captured, tortured, disappeared and found dead." Shortly after our meeting, Romero was assassinated by graduates of the School of the Americas. In 1996, after pressure by School of the Americas Watch and other human rights organizations, the Pentagon was forced to release torture manuals that had been translated into Spanish and used in courses at the School of the Americas for at least a decade. I have interviewed many survivors of these horrendous tragedies, including some who were actual participants in the death squads. They told me that those involved in their training were U.S. military officers, some of whom were even present at the scenes of torture. After hearing this firsthand testimony, I and others committed civil disobedience at Fort Benning at the annual protest in November 2001. As a U.S. Air Force veteran, I wanted to speak out against the role my country had played in these atrocities. For this action, I was sentenced to three months in federal prison.

Last November, once again I joined 19,000 people at the gates of Fort Benning in the solemn vigil. Thirty-seven of us crossed onto the military base in a nonviolent witness of conscience. This time, we protested not only the history of torture at this place, but the apparent continuation of these practices by our own military in places such as Iraq, Afghanistan, Guantanamo Bay Naval Station or outsourced by U.S. agencies to other countries, such as Egypt, Syria, and Jordan, according to Amnesty International. Survivors of torture in Latin America address the crowd at this massive gathering, and many asked the same thing: "Why are the same methods of torture now being committed by the U.S. military so similar to those that were used on us?"

I was tried and convicted of trespass and am serving my six months' sentence in Crisp County Jail in Georgia. During my time in prison, I have reflected on questions regarding these issues:

These activities have raised troubling questions for all concerned citizens. True democracy cannot be imposed by the use of forcee that breds anger and desperation; but can be through policies that promote understanding, fairness and compassion.

Louis Vitale is a Franciscan friar of the Santa Barbara Province, and the former pastor of St. Boniface Catholic Church in San Francisco. He is co-founder of Pace e Bene Nonviolence Service and a member of the School of the Americas Watch and

Articles and Reprints


CIA quits resisting, lets old skeletons out of the closet
Lugar shakes Capitol, Key GOP senator calls Bush Iraq strategy a failure
Gulf of Tonkin intelligence called "deliberately skewed"
FBI agents saw detainees abused by US. military
Detainee tells rights panel of abuse at Guantanamo
US security firms sendings hundreds of Salvadorans to Iraq
US accused of AIDS drug conspiracy
Nigerian troops accused in killings
Terrorist Mercenaries on U.S. Payroll in Iraq War


Evo Morales and the roots of revolution
President Bush: Where we at?
Venezuelan warns of U.S. overthrow
President Bush: Where we at?
Get Out Now, Before We Are Thrown Out
Opening the Gates of Hell
Sacrifice Iraq for Israel's Security


American Genetics & Nazi Eugenics
Dude, where's my country?
Thinking Past Terror
Kilometer Zero
Torture should never be U.S. policy


White Phosphorus and folks
Why I will hold my nose and vote for kerry
Perhaps 9/11 was allowed to happen
Denial is not an option
The old paradigm, the new paradigm
Emotionless killers, tearless victims
Israel's financial debt to the U.S.
Hypocrisy condemned at IMF meeting
U.S. stonewalls on greenhouse gas emission pact
U.S. teaches children to consume (conspicuously)
Ignorance is not bliss
Downsizing Americans
Flight 103: The CIA set-up continues
Mad for cows


Mandela rips Bush for policy on Iraq
Child slave trade stirs little outrage
More & more slavery
The new slavery
Action against the new slavery
Subtle racism
Casualties of the global economy
Hate's genesis
Mumia Abu-Jamal
A presidential pardon for the wrong man
Fact sheet on Palestine/Israel relations
A pilgrim's guide to Bethlehem
Student movement counters Israeli apartheid
The curse of the infidel
Torture and rape stalk the streets of Chechnya
Asleep at several wheels


New Orleans Musicians may come to San Francisco
An accounting scandal that could dwarf ENRON
Some people still don't want you to see
Arianna on Cheney
The meaning of war with Iraq
Side tale of 911
Philippines -- The next target of Bush's war
U.S. attacks its citizens
What really happened September 11th?
What keeps America on top: drugs, guns and slaves
The US is now a threat to the rest of the world
The fireball and the ice pick
The temptations of empire
America's terrorist training camp
War won't end terrorism


Iraq: 21st century colonial oppression
Senator Byrd on the Arrogance of Power
Robin Cook resigns House of Commons
Bush issues War Ultimatum
Stop the War!
Who Armed Iraq?
Oil War Profiteers Plan Ahead
Who will fight the war?
Who Will Suffer?
The Final Solution
Do they really want Mr. bin Laden -- or do they want access to the oil?
Alternatives to war: The U.S. versus Iraq
U.S. thinking the unthinkable
Is Iraq a true threat to the US? Weapons Inspector speaks
The war against terrorism is a fraud
Iraq may be next
Iraq Briefing: Oil, Oil, Oil
Islam and the West: A clash of justice versus greed
Iraq Briefing: U.S. Lies, Lies, Lies
Dying for oil
Letter by former U.S. Attorney General Ramsey Clark sent to all members of the UN Security Council
U.S. Connection in weapons of mass destruction
Student movement counters Iraq war drive
If Iraq lets the arms inspectors back in, America's case for war will be exposed as fiction

Subway Guitars
1800 Cedar Street
Berkeley, California 94703

Telephone: (510) 841-4106
noon til six, Monday thru Saturday
Pacific Time